All Immigration matters, including temporary, visitor, work, SMC, investor and residency visas: Immigration Trust - Immigration Law Expert in Auckland, Wellington, and ChristChurch, New Zealand
  • Home
    • RoadShow >
      • Jakarta-Indonesia >
        • Jakarta-Free
      • Hanoi-Vietnam
    • Arabic
    • Chinese
    • Spanish
  • About Us
    • Executive Team >
      • Founder & CEO
      • Principal Consultant Lawyer
      • Client Manager
      • Office Manager
      • Intern
    • Specialist Team >
      • Professor Siah Ang
      • Fay Nie
    • Advisory Board >
      • Ming Lim-Pollard
      • Edwin Paul
      • Prabha Ravi QSM JP
      • Shan Ng
      • Amit Prasad
      • Dr Sarkaw Mohammad
      • Fang Yang
    • Education >
      • Support Package
      • Cost
    • Contact
    • Disclaimer/Privacy Policy
  • Services
    • How we work >
      • Report to INZ
    • Fees
    • Visitor Visa >
      • Covid Visa
    • Study Visa
    • Work Visa >
      • Changes to Essential Skills work visa
      • Short term changes to visa settings for temporary work visa holders in New Zealand
      • New Skills Match Report
      • Changes to Employer Assisted Work Visas
      • Post Study Work Visa
      • Remove Employer Assisted
    • Interim Visa
    • SMC >
      • Possible questions from your case officer to your employer
      • List of ANZSCO occupations treated as an exception
      • SMC Assessment Service
    • Resident Visa
    • Parent Visa
    • Partnership Visa >
      • Partner Visa Case Assessment
    • Entrepreneur Work Visa
    • Entrepreneur Residence Visa
    • Variations of Conditions
    • Investor Visa
    • PPI >
      • PPI-Urgent Assessment Service
    • BONA FIDE
    • Reconsideration >
      • Reconsideration Assessment Service
    • Unlawful
    • Residence and reporting requirements
    • Section 61 >
      • Section 61 More examples
      • Section 61 More examples2
      • Section 61 More examples3
      • Section 61 More examples4
      • Section 61 Feedback
      • Section 61 Feedback 2
      • Section 61 Fee
      • Section 61 -2
      • Section 61 Assessment
    • Visa declined >
      • Declined Visa Assessment
    • Medical Waiver >
      • Medical Waiver Assessment Service
    • Character Waiver >
      • Character Waiver Assessment
    • Appeal Review
    • Ministerial Intervention >
      • Ministerial Intervention Assessment Service
    • Deportation
    • Complaint to INZ
    • Employer Assistance
  • Forms & Guides
    • New Zealand Immigration Forms >
      • Online Fillable New Zealand Immigration Forms
      • INZ1017-Visitor Visa Application
      • INZ1111-Visitor Visa Application for Auckland Region Applicants
      • INZ1189-Tourist Business Visitor Visa Application
      • INZ1172-Temporary Retirement Category Visitor Visa Application
      • INZ1205-Additional Dependants for a Visitor Visa
      • INZ1083-Guide for Visitors Arriving by Yacht
      • INZ1021-Group Visa Application
      • INZ1022-Additional Group Visa Application
      • INZ1025-Sponsorship Form for Temporary Entry
      • INZ1019-Transit Visa Application
      • INZ1155-Group Transit Application
      • INZ1156-Additional Group Transit Application
      • INZ1027-Supplementary Form 补充表
      • INZ1188-China Tourist Visitor Visa Application
      • INZ1220-Supplementary Form
      • INZ1177-Military Visa Application
      • INZ1012-Student Visa Application
      • INZ1014-Financial Undertaking for a Student
      • INZ1217-Verpflichtungserklärung über die finanzielle Unterstützung eines Studenten/Schülers Financial Undertaking for a Student
      • INZ1146-Form for Partners Supporting Partnership-Based Temporary Entry Applications
      • INZ1015-Work Visa Application
      • INZ1020-Application for a Variation of Conditions or a Variation of Travel Conditions
      • INZ1223-Working Holiday Scheme Second Work Visa Application
      • INZ1187-Performing Artists, Entertainers and Entertainment Industry Personnel Work Visa Application
      • INZ1113-Employer Supplementary Form
      • INZ1091-Talent (Arts, Culture and Sports) Sponsorship Form
      • INZ1190-Sponsorship Form for Religious Workers
      • INZ1198-Partnership-Based Temporary Visa Application
      • INZ1158-Work Visa Application for China Skilled Work Instructions
      • INZ1204-Request for Approval in Principle to Recruit Foreign Crew of Fishing Vessels
      • INZ1153-SSE/WHE Work Visa Application
      • INZ1212-Formal Notification of Crew Deserter
      • INZ1142-Application to Work for a Recognised Seasonal Employer
      • INZ1090-Employer Accreditation Application
      • INZ1112-Request for Approval in Principle
      • INZ1140-Application for Recognised Seasonal Employer Status
      • INZ1167-Supplementary Seasonal Employment Approval in Principle
      • INZ1178-Partnership Support Form for Residence
      • INZ1141-Application for an Agreement to Recruit
      • INZ1197-Entertainment Industry Accreditation Application
      • INZ1227-Labour Hire Employer Accreditation Application
      • INZ1000-Residence Application
      • INZ1000-Online Fillable Form
      • INZ1202-Parent Category Expression of Interest Form
      • INZ1206-Parent Category Residence Application
      • INZ1024-Sponsorship Form For Residence
      • INZ1100-​Expression of Interest Form
      • INZ1094-Refugee Family Support Category Tier One Sponsor Registration Form
      • INZ1103-​Expression of Interest Form Child Supplement
      • INZ1170-Parent Retirement Category Residence Application
      • INZ1192-Refugee Family Support Category Tier Two Sponsor Registration Form
      • INZ1175-Application from a Resident or Former Resident Visa Holder
      • INZ1001-Additional Dependants for Residence in New Zealand
      • INZ1115-Skilled Migrant Category Application for Residence
      • INZ1222-Entrepreneur Work Visa Application
      • INZ1056-Entrepreneur Residence Application
      • INZ 1242-Partner and Child Resident Visa Declaration Form
      • INZ 1241-Partner and Child Temporary Visa Declaration Form
    • New Zealand Immigration Guides >
      • INZ 1199 Partnership-Based Temporary Visa Guide
      • INZ1016 Work Visa Guide
    • New Zealand Visa Applications Fee
    • Exceptions to NZ border closure
    • New Zealand Visa Processing Time
    • New Zealand Visa Prevent Delays
    • New Zealand Police Certificate
    • Visa Photos
    • New Zealand Immigration News
  • Appointment
    • Appointment-Overseas
    • Free Assessment
  • Payment
    • Ask a question
    • Urgent Case
    • Case Management Service
    • Job Assessment Service
    • Full Assessment Service >
      • Terms and Conditions

New Zealand Immigration News​

Immigrants like ‘slaves’ under broken system

6/12/2017

0 Comments

 
Immigration New Zealand, www.immigrationtrust.co.nz
Down in Wellington, there’s a young Indian man managing a dairy.
He also drives his employer and his wife around town, cooks dinner, cleans, and does other household chores.

Racking up 120 hours, over seven days a week, he is paid about $5 an hour for his efforts.
“They’re basically a slave”, immigration lawyer Alistair McClymont explains while recounting the tale, which he says is far from uncommon.

While the tourism boom is easily noticed, there has also been a huge increase in recent years in the number of people arriving in New Zealand to study and work.

A byproduct of that has been a rapid jump in visa fraud, migrant exploitation, and even human trafficking.

In a recent interview with Newsroom, new Immigration Minister Iain Lees-Galloway said the visa system “lacked integrity” and was being abused.  He had been shocked to read in a briefing that Immigration New Zealand (INZ) was investigating only a sliver of the fraud and exploitation complaints it received.
In 2015/16 INZ investigated only a third of cases that met its criteria, with that number plunging to just 18 percent in the last financial year.

Lees-Galloway blamed the issue on a lack of funding, but said finding extra money would be difficult.
Immigration lawyers spoken to were far from shocked when told about the low investigation rate.
Auckland-based McClymont said there was a myriad of fraud schemes, with employers who were experts at finding loopholes.  “I’m not in the slightest bit surprised, I’m surprised it’s that high to be honest.”
When he directed people to INZ to report fraud and abuse, nine out of 10 times they took a statement and never got back in touch, he said.

Students were most at risk, having spent tens of thousands of dollars to get to New Zealand.
Having invested so much they were desperate to stay and employers took advantage.
“Some employers who have been accused say students have been lining up to work for 70, 80 hours for free because they’re desperate for residence visas,” McClymont said.

Richard Fletcher, a Wellington-based immigration lawyer, agreed there was a strain on the system.
He wondered whether INZ had the skills and expertise needed considering resource constraints and was curious about what their enforcement priorities were.

“I’m looking forward to reading the briefings to incoming ministers and seeing what they’ve got to say about themselves.”  

Whether more of these cases can be dealt with will largely depend on whether INZ and its minister can find any extra money.

Despite a 25 percent budget increase since 2015 most of the money had been soaked up by other areas and offset by the population increase.

INZ assistant general manager Peter Devoy said the rise in the number of people partly explained the jump in fraud and exploitation cases, but not completely.

“To some extent unsurprisingly the number of complaints have gone up, the extent to which they’ve gone up is the surprising aspect and it is something that is of concern that we’ve signalled to the Minister.”
With the resources they had INZ was focusing on the pointy end of exploitation, with more minor complaints referred to other agencies or simply not being dealt with.

Serious exploitation such as human trafficking was a priority, with the third prosecution currently before the courts.  These were situations where people had been lured by the promise of a job but were being forced to work long hours for little pay.

“The work we’re doing is good work, we’d like to be doing more of it.
“There’s always more, it’s always that situation, there’s always another rock to turn over and go and have a look.”

To read the actual article, visit here.

Who we are
How we work
Free consultation

0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.


New Zealand Wellington Free Immigration Advice help - Immigration Trust
Copyright © 2013 - 2021 Immigration Trust.
All rights reserved.
​Immigration Law Experts
Licensed Immigration Advisers
Disclaimer/Privacy Policy​  
​
The logo of Immigration Trust is a Registered Trademark 
​

Our clients' feedback


Total visits to Immigration Trust
View Simon Park QSM JP's LinkedIn profile View Simon Park QSM JP's profile
Picture

  • Home
    • RoadShow >
      • Jakarta-Indonesia >
        • Jakarta-Free
      • Hanoi-Vietnam
    • Arabic
    • Chinese
    • Spanish
  • About Us
    • Executive Team >
      • Founder & CEO
      • Principal Consultant Lawyer
      • Client Manager
      • Office Manager
      • Intern
    • Specialist Team >
      • Professor Siah Ang
      • Fay Nie
    • Advisory Board >
      • Ming Lim-Pollard
      • Edwin Paul
      • Prabha Ravi QSM JP
      • Shan Ng
      • Amit Prasad
      • Dr Sarkaw Mohammad
      • Fang Yang
    • Education >
      • Support Package
      • Cost
    • Contact
    • Disclaimer/Privacy Policy
  • Services
    • How we work >
      • Report to INZ
    • Fees
    • Visitor Visa >
      • Covid Visa
    • Study Visa
    • Work Visa >
      • Changes to Essential Skills work visa
      • Short term changes to visa settings for temporary work visa holders in New Zealand
      • New Skills Match Report
      • Changes to Employer Assisted Work Visas
      • Post Study Work Visa
      • Remove Employer Assisted
    • Interim Visa
    • SMC >
      • Possible questions from your case officer to your employer
      • List of ANZSCO occupations treated as an exception
      • SMC Assessment Service
    • Resident Visa
    • Parent Visa
    • Partnership Visa >
      • Partner Visa Case Assessment
    • Entrepreneur Work Visa
    • Entrepreneur Residence Visa
    • Variations of Conditions
    • Investor Visa
    • PPI >
      • PPI-Urgent Assessment Service
    • BONA FIDE
    • Reconsideration >
      • Reconsideration Assessment Service
    • Unlawful
    • Residence and reporting requirements
    • Section 61 >
      • Section 61 More examples
      • Section 61 More examples2
      • Section 61 More examples3
      • Section 61 More examples4
      • Section 61 Feedback
      • Section 61 Feedback 2
      • Section 61 Fee
      • Section 61 -2
      • Section 61 Assessment
    • Visa declined >
      • Declined Visa Assessment
    • Medical Waiver >
      • Medical Waiver Assessment Service
    • Character Waiver >
      • Character Waiver Assessment
    • Appeal Review
    • Ministerial Intervention >
      • Ministerial Intervention Assessment Service
    • Deportation
    • Complaint to INZ
    • Employer Assistance
  • Forms & Guides
    • New Zealand Immigration Forms >
      • Online Fillable New Zealand Immigration Forms
      • INZ1017-Visitor Visa Application
      • INZ1111-Visitor Visa Application for Auckland Region Applicants
      • INZ1189-Tourist Business Visitor Visa Application
      • INZ1172-Temporary Retirement Category Visitor Visa Application
      • INZ1205-Additional Dependants for a Visitor Visa
      • INZ1083-Guide for Visitors Arriving by Yacht
      • INZ1021-Group Visa Application
      • INZ1022-Additional Group Visa Application
      • INZ1025-Sponsorship Form for Temporary Entry
      • INZ1019-Transit Visa Application
      • INZ1155-Group Transit Application
      • INZ1156-Additional Group Transit Application
      • INZ1027-Supplementary Form 补充表
      • INZ1188-China Tourist Visitor Visa Application
      • INZ1220-Supplementary Form
      • INZ1177-Military Visa Application
      • INZ1012-Student Visa Application
      • INZ1014-Financial Undertaking for a Student
      • INZ1217-Verpflichtungserklärung über die finanzielle Unterstützung eines Studenten/Schülers Financial Undertaking for a Student
      • INZ1146-Form for Partners Supporting Partnership-Based Temporary Entry Applications
      • INZ1015-Work Visa Application
      • INZ1020-Application for a Variation of Conditions or a Variation of Travel Conditions
      • INZ1223-Working Holiday Scheme Second Work Visa Application
      • INZ1187-Performing Artists, Entertainers and Entertainment Industry Personnel Work Visa Application
      • INZ1113-Employer Supplementary Form
      • INZ1091-Talent (Arts, Culture and Sports) Sponsorship Form
      • INZ1190-Sponsorship Form for Religious Workers
      • INZ1198-Partnership-Based Temporary Visa Application
      • INZ1158-Work Visa Application for China Skilled Work Instructions
      • INZ1204-Request for Approval in Principle to Recruit Foreign Crew of Fishing Vessels
      • INZ1153-SSE/WHE Work Visa Application
      • INZ1212-Formal Notification of Crew Deserter
      • INZ1142-Application to Work for a Recognised Seasonal Employer
      • INZ1090-Employer Accreditation Application
      • INZ1112-Request for Approval in Principle
      • INZ1140-Application for Recognised Seasonal Employer Status
      • INZ1167-Supplementary Seasonal Employment Approval in Principle
      • INZ1178-Partnership Support Form for Residence
      • INZ1141-Application for an Agreement to Recruit
      • INZ1197-Entertainment Industry Accreditation Application
      • INZ1227-Labour Hire Employer Accreditation Application
      • INZ1000-Residence Application
      • INZ1000-Online Fillable Form
      • INZ1202-Parent Category Expression of Interest Form
      • INZ1206-Parent Category Residence Application
      • INZ1024-Sponsorship Form For Residence
      • INZ1100-​Expression of Interest Form
      • INZ1094-Refugee Family Support Category Tier One Sponsor Registration Form
      • INZ1103-​Expression of Interest Form Child Supplement
      • INZ1170-Parent Retirement Category Residence Application
      • INZ1192-Refugee Family Support Category Tier Two Sponsor Registration Form
      • INZ1175-Application from a Resident or Former Resident Visa Holder
      • INZ1001-Additional Dependants for Residence in New Zealand
      • INZ1115-Skilled Migrant Category Application for Residence
      • INZ1222-Entrepreneur Work Visa Application
      • INZ1056-Entrepreneur Residence Application
      • INZ 1242-Partner and Child Resident Visa Declaration Form
      • INZ 1241-Partner and Child Temporary Visa Declaration Form
    • New Zealand Immigration Guides >
      • INZ 1199 Partnership-Based Temporary Visa Guide
      • INZ1016 Work Visa Guide
    • New Zealand Visa Applications Fee
    • Exceptions to NZ border closure
    • New Zealand Visa Processing Time
    • New Zealand Visa Prevent Delays
    • New Zealand Police Certificate
    • Visa Photos
    • New Zealand Immigration News
  • Appointment
    • Appointment-Overseas
    • Free Assessment
  • Payment
    • Ask a question
    • Urgent Case
    • Case Management Service
    • Job Assessment Service
    • Full Assessment Service >
      • Terms and Conditions